Lego Pirates
The Lego theme that gave minifigures something other than a plain smile. Starting in 1989, Captain Redbeard and his crew had eyepatches, beards, a hook and a peg leg, and they sailed ships with cloth sails against soldiers in blue coats. The first big ship, the Black Seas Barracuda, is still the one the others are measured against.
The story
Lego introduced Pirates in 1989. The company's own history calls it one of the first new themes since Town, Castle and Space launched in the late 1970s, and it needed a great many new parts: pieces for building large sailing ships, cloth sails, a parrot, a monkey and a shark, treasure chests and gold coins. It also had Lego's first firearms. The company's rule is that it makes only historical and fantasy weapons, and flintlock pistols, muskets and cannons qualified.
It needed new faces too. Until then a minifigure had two dots for eyes and a smile. "It was necessary to alter the minifigure's expression in order to develop credible pirates," the designer Jens Nygaard Knudsen explained, "and a real pirate captain must have a patch on his eye, a peg leg and a hook!" So Captain Redbeard, called Captain Roger in some countries, got a patch over his left eye, a hook for a left hand and a wooden right leg. His crew got beards and moustaches, and lipstick appeared as well. The smile underneath, Lego notes, held on for years.
Against the pirates stood Governor Broadside's blue-coated soldiers, replaced by redcoats in 1992 and 1993. Islanders joined in 1994 and a Spanish-style armada in 1996. The flagship was set 6285, a ship most fans know as the Black Seas Barracuda, though Lego says most of its catalogs at the time called it the Dark Shark. The boxes for the big sets had a flap that lifted to show the contents through a window. In 1995 skeletons turned up in Pirates and Castle sets, Lego's first. The designer Niels Milan Pedersen said the figure had been drawn up a decade earlier and shelved: "we were told off at the time for creating a dead minifigure!"
The original run ended after 1997. Lego brought the theme back in 2009 for its twentieth anniversary and again in 2015, and it keeps returning to the 1989 sets. The Barracuda was reissued in 2002 and reimagined in 2020 as a ship that can also be built as a shipwreck island, and the governor's Eldorado Fortress came back in 2023.
Bring it back
More like this
Bionicle
2001–2010
LEGO's buildable biomechanical warriors, sold in collectible canisters and wrapped in a sprawling island mythology kids argued about at recess. Part toy, part epic saga — you built the heroes, collected their masks, and followed the lore across comics, books, and films.
Lego Star Wars: The Video Game
2005
You and your sibling on the couch, dropping in and out whenever someone's mom called dinner, one of you smashing everything for studs while the other solved the puzzles. This wasn't the grim prequels — this was pantomime comedy and fifty-nine characters to unlock.
K'NEX
1990s
A construction toy of colorful plastic rods and connectors that snapped together to build structures, vehicles, and elaborate motorized contraptions like Ferris wheels and roller coasters. Invented by Joel Glickman and launched in 1992, K'NEX was the rods-and-connectors alternative to LEGO's bricks, and it rewarded imagination and structural thinking with click-satisfying mechanical systems.
Lincoln Logs
1916–present
Notched wooden logs that stack and interlock into cabins, towers, and forts — a toy essentially unchanged since 1916, when architect Frank Lloyd Wright's son John adapted his father's earthquake-resistant design into a 3/4-inch timber puzzle. By the 90s, that tin of logs was in every classroom, den, and grandparent's closet, a multi-generational constant.